New or old Zelda

[BaconWarrior]

Which is better 2d or 3d Zelda.

Personnaly I like 3d Zelda better, I rather be able to move around and ride a hoarse and stuff.

[Hi no Seijin]

On the one hand, you have MM.  On the other hand, you have the Tarm Ruins.  Either way, you forgot the comedy option.  For shame.

[DW]

He has one, I mean, what kind of person wouldn't be sure!

Haha, haha, ha....ha...*sniff*....

[IronKnuckle]

The 3D. Its much eisier to feel connected to a world if the world isn't a bunch of sprites and pixles.

[Bboy94]

I'm not sure.

LttP and TP are a equal in my mind, for different things. Too hard to choose, I like the realism of 3D, but the atmosphere of 2D...

[Takun]

I agree with that.

[BaconWarrior]

You have a point, I like TP OoC better than LttP but then I still like the old 2D Zelda its hard to choose.

[Vaati]

Definately 3D Zelda. Definately, definately!

[DW]

2D, nostalgia is a beautiful thing. Plus it allows for a lot of puzzles you couldn't do in 3D as it would break the laws of physics. I also like seeing things that you're not looking in the direction of.

[BaconWarrior]

Yeah but you cant block sword or melee attacks with your shield in 2D only arrows.

[Bboy94]

2D:
Puzzles, nostalgia, top-down
3D:
Cool battle system, more realistic

2D is winning.

[Zelda Veteran]

Honestly, if I were given the choice, I would play 3D zelda games instead. It really brings Hyrule and its places to life in a way that a 2D game never could, and never will. I like the old games, but the new games have some amazing stuff packed into them. Like the fight with that dragon in TP: Magnificent.

[BaconWarrior]

2D:
Puzzles, nostalgia, top-down
3D:
Cool battle system, more realistic

2D is winning.

Depends on if you like combat or the puzzles better, personnaly I kinda dislike the puzzles...

[Fishalicious]

And I love puzzles, particularly difficult ones, over combat... Anyway, I would say that I love 2D more... but I'm in love with art, and 2D games aren't... as visually or aesthetically pleasing.

I'm all for destroying laws of physics, though, so 2D it is.

[Bboy94]

Ok, after plugging in my SNES, and playing LttP, nostalgia overwhelmed me, and I choose 2D.