If Hyrule Were On Earth...

[Vaati]

Where do you think it would be? I'm guessing in Europe somewhere. Either around Greece, or Scandinavia.

[TP Zelda]

It depends on which one.

If it's TWW, I think somewhere in the Pacific Ocean.

If it's OoT, somewhere in Hawaii? XD

[Keaton]

Hawaii?  O_o

Let's see:

Legend of Zelda - New Mexico

Adventure of Link - Iceland

A Link to the Past - Canada!

Link's Awakening - The Caribbean Islands

Ocarina of Time - Scotland

Majora's Mask - As I've stated before, I think it's just a state of mind.

The Wind Waker - Postapocalyptic Pacific

Twilight Princess - Germany

Tingle's Rosy Rupeeland - San Francisco

[TP Zelda]

Tingles what-now?

[Commodore Axilon]

Tingle's Rosy Rupeeland - San Francisco

I can't roll my eyes hard enough at this.

[HylianHero92]

TWW would take place in the Mediterranean Sea 'cause in the Bible the Mediterranean Sea is called the Great Sea... sounds familiar  

[Keaton]

TWW would take place in the Mediterranean Sea 'cause in the Bible the Mediterranean Sea is called the Great Sea... sounds familiar  

That's actually moderately brilliant.

[MagmarFire]

*moves to General Zelda; not really a discussion on Compendium-esque theory*

And major lulz on the Rupeeland location, Tacheon.

[Zelda Veteran]

Why Thanfranthithco thilly boy?

[Vaati]

All this talk about the different games gets me thinking again.

Legend of Zelda, Adventures of Link, A Link to the Past - England
Link's Awakening - Hawaii
Ocarina of Time, Twilight Princess - Germany
Majora's Mask - Poland
Wind Waker - Greece
Phantom Hourglass - Australia
Oracle Series - ...Wales?
Minish Cap, Four Swords/Adventure - Finland

Tingle's Rosy Rupeeland - San Francisco

I can't roll my eyes hard enough at this.

No...Massachusetts! Provincetown to be exact. jk.  

[JoeLink]

Why don't people realize that Hyrule IS(or rather WAS)on Earth?! It is SO obvious.

[MagmarFire]

Or an alternate version of Earth, or maybe just a similar planet entirely. Any of the three mentioned are just as likely.

[Hi no Seijin]

Why don't people realize that Hyrule IS(or rather WAS)on Earth?! It is SO obvious.

Assuming this isn't a joke, I don't see how it's obvious that Hyrule is, or was, on Earth.  You're going to have to explain this.

So, if Hyrule was on Earth.  I always thought that Hyrule seemed somewhat related to the Celts, so I would say the British Isles.

[JoeLink]

Where do I begin?....
1.) Earth flora and fauna
2.) constellations in the night sky only visible from Earth (casseopia, Orion, the big dipper.)
3.) the sun rising in the east and setting in the west
4.) humans (only found on Earth. durr.)
5.) characters in TWW referring to the planet Earth (not earth as in dirt, the PLANET EARTH.)

If these don't convince you, then....I feel sorry for you.

[DW]

Where do I begin?....
1.) Earth flora and fauna
2.) constellations in the night sky only visible from Earth (casseopia, Orion, the big dipper.)
3.) the sun rising in the east and setting in the west
4.) humans (only found on Earth. durr.)
5.) characters in TWW referring to the planet Earth (not earth as in dirt, the PLANET EARTH.)

If these don't convince you, then....I feel sorry for you.

Counter points:

1.) Yeah, the tree in my backyard talks to me all the time.
2.) NEVER can two different groups of stars make the same pattern.
3.) Out of two choices, this isn't solid evidence.
4.) Hylians? Gerudo?
5.) Prove it. I don't remember this.