Pokemon Heartgold/Soulsilver.

[Deku]

I've always raised a Gengar when it was possible as well.
I also always choose the Water starter first. I loved Squirtle and Totadile. Mudkip was alright, and Piplup was just terrible. I wish I'd've chosen Turtwig. My favorites of startes for the generations were:
Squirtle>Bulbasaur=Charmander (this gen was magical)
Totadile>Cyndaquill=Chikorita (loved second gen)
Torchic>Mudkip>Treeko (this gen was awesome, but not comparable to 1st and 2nd)
I didn't like any of the 4th gen starters that much. I eventually just threw Prinplup out of the team completely. I also love Ninetales, and raise it whenever possible. I'm a diehard first generation fan, and always will be. If I had to assemble a team to travel with through an entire game, it'd be composed completely of the first to ever explode onto the scene.

[DW]

The Great Marsh is a real pain in the butt.

[MagmarFire]

Agreed. They definitely need, like, water shoes or something so you don't fall in. >_<

The snow near Snowpoint is kind of worse, though >.>

[DW]

I mean, it's impossible to get anything. Like, I finally got a Paras. I've had God knows how many Azumarills get away, and now this Carvanha won't stay in the damn ball.

I need these pokemon

Edit: OHMYGOD I CAUGHT THE CARVANHA HAPPY FACE

I shall name him Jimmy Stewart. Or some shorter version of that name.

[MagmarFire]

What balls are you using, exactly?

[DW]

You can only use Safari Balls and YES I CAUGHT THE CARVANHA

[Fishalicious]

My favourite starters are like this:

Bulbasaur > Charmander > Squirtle
Totodile > Cyndaquil > Chikorita (this is really hard to decide with)
Treecko > Torchic > Mudkip
LOL 4TH GEN POKEMON. I like Empoleon because I love Steel c:

anddd I just said screw the great marsh. I miss the safari zone. rrrrr Nidorino and Kangaskhan come back ;;

[DW]

You can still get them...though I think for Kangaskhan you need Ruby or Sapphire in the GBA slot.

And yeah, I wanna never come back either but there are some pokemon I have to get here.

Hey Fisk we should battle or trade or something.

[Fishalicious]

Oh, yeah, I'd love to battle you eventually... would you mind waiting until next week? I'm in the volcano level with Buck training my Nidoking and Vaporeon and it's a while to get back to a pokemon center.

[DW]

I'm still tromping around the Marsh (I wasted five balls and countless mud chunks and bait on Marill and still didn't get him ;_;)

But yeah I can do it later.

EDIT: Is it possible to partner up for the battle tower over Wi-Fi? Without fighting each other?

[TP Zelda]

I hate the Elite 4.

[Rev Rabies]

i want all...
LOL jk
Dragonite Ponyta and Gengar oooooo
And Blastoise :OO

Gengar is mine, he's part of my main team, but i might be able to say goodbye to the others for a price, just remember, dratini is very hard to find shiny because she's in the water which you can't use pokeradar for.

lol ok =ppp

for a price?XDD

meh, if i had to choose two i'd mostly want dragonite and blastoise  :P

but for a price sure that'd make me feel better  :-[

blastoise is mine too, you will never have him, i can try and breed you a shiny squirt tho.

and ZV, you make me cry, empoleon is win, but blastoise is the best water starter in my opinion

[TP Zelda]

i want all...
LOL jk
Dragonite Ponyta and Gengar oooooo
And Blastoise :OO

Gengar is mine, he's part of my main team, but i might be able to say goodbye to the others for a price, just remember, dratini is very hard to find shiny because she's in the water which you can't use pokeradar for.

lol ok =ppp

for a price?XDD

meh, if i had to choose two i'd mostly want dragonite and blastoise  :P

but for a price sure that'd make me feel better  :-[

blastoise is mine too, you will never have him, i can try and breed you a shiny squirt tho.

and ZV, you make me cry, empoleon is win, but blastoise is the best water starter in my opinion

lmfao okai

and yeah empoleon sucks WHEN YOU ONLY AHVE A 5PP MOVE THAT YOU CAN'T BEAT THE ELITE 4 WITH

[MagmarFire]

Is it Blizzard? If so, Empoleon doesn't get a STAB from it (excluding NeverMeltIce)... >.>

Fire, Dark, Water, and Electric, FTW.

[TP Zelda]

No, it's Hydro Pump. I can only replace one move, because I like Bind and my other two movesa re HM moves grah >.>

But Hyrdo Pump kills like, everything I battle so XP

edit: I can't spell Hydro D: