• Welcome to The Desert Colossus.
 

News:

Welcome to the Desert!  Register, post, and have fun.  Why not introduce yourself in the
Welcome Thread?

Main Menu

i haz question.

Started by TP Zelda, October 14, 2009, 06:51:14 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

TP Zelda

iz tere difference between hylian and hyrulian

MagmarFire

Hylian seems to be a species, whereas Hyrulean seems to be an identifier of location. Like American.



Advanceshipping and Rion had better be Chuck Norris approved.

TP Zelda

so loikes, yew would say........

Zelda is Hylian.......
or
They're Hyrulean.
?

darkphantomime

Quote from: MagmarFire on October 14, 2009, 07:07:11 PM
Hylian seems to be a species, whereas Hyrulean seems to be an identifier of location. Like American.

Good, now just think for a few minutes about how that'll work when done in the original japanese.

In my book, they're the same.

Hi no Seijin

Except that the country is called Hyrule, so Hyrulean would most likely be used to denote a citizen of Hyrule, whereas Hylian would identify the race.
Best.  Cane.  EVER!
Secretary of Lolcats; I won the MagmarFire Award for 2/21/08!
Filler.Filler.Filler.Fillah!  Filler.Filler.Filler.Fillah!

MagmarFire

Quote from: JQ Pickwick on October 14, 2009, 07:54:06 PM
Good, now just think for a few minutes about how that'll work when done in the original japanese.

In my book, they're the same.

Which is why I said, "seems to be," not, "is most definitely so, and you're a Nazi if you don't think the same."

In my book, either variant will do, but I'm choosing one that makes sense to me. :/



Advanceshipping and Rion had better be Chuck Norris approved.

Darth Wyndisis

The Hylians are from Eastern Hyrule and the Hyruleans are from Western Hyrule, and anybody who doesn't think the same is a Nazi.

Deku

Quote from: MagmarFire on October 14, 2009, 07:07:11 PM
Hylian seems to be a species, whereas Hyrulean seems to be an identifier of location. Like American.
Magmar is right. Hylian is a race of people who are closer to the Goddesses than any other race. Hyrule is the kingdom ruled by Hylians. If you're Hyrulean(sp?), then you're a citizen of Hyrule. A Goron can be Hyrulean. Hope that clears things up :)

darkphantomime

It still doesn't, because how does that end up working out in the original japanese?

DW

­

MagmarFire




Advanceshipping and Rion had better be Chuck Norris approved.