• Welcome to The Desert Colossus.
 

News:

Welcome to the Desert!  Register, post, and have fun.  Why not introduce yourself in the
Welcome Thread?

Main Menu

OOT isn't LttPs backstory!

Started by Penguin dude 2, April 13, 2007, 03:50:56 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

Penguin dude 2

I finally have proof that OoT isn't LttPs backstory!
1=the adult timeline=This has TWW, which explians that Ganons seal weakened enough for him to break out, and take out Hyrule. He eventually dies at the end with the Master Sword in his head.
2=kid timeline=Link gets sent back, and MM happens, and then TP later. TP showed Ganon getting executed, it failed, and he was sent into the Twilight Realm. Aonuma(or Miyamoto, I can't remember who said this) stated that Link was sent back right before he talked to Zelda, and as a result, they talked to the king, and after Ganon did something entirely crazy, they decied to kill him. It failed and later, TP happened.
3= other evidence= the Imprisoning War= LttP backstory stated that people found the Golden Land, and they found out about the Triforce, which they called the Golden Power. Ganon got it 1st which was stated multiple times in the game. It then stated that so many were going into the Golden Land, and fighting each other, that the 7 Sages sealed it, but people knew, and they attacked them. The Knights of Hyrule held them off, but the casting took so long that they were almost all wiped out.
This almost entirely contradicts OoT, as Link fought Ganon to kill him, but he was only able to put him in the Evil Realm. The Sages took only a few seconds to cast the spell, without Zelda, who was the 7th Sage. There wasn't a single soldier left alive to protect the Sages, but they were also in the Temple of Light, which was in the Sacred Realm. Also, people weren't seeking the Triforce, though they might have known of its existence. Ganon only had the ToP, and Link and Zelda had the rest. No person knew of the Sages involvement except Link and Zelda. Aside from Ganon getting sealed in the Sacred Realm, nothing else is really the same.
You might be able to say some of it could correlate by the legend getting obscured by time, but things like the Sages coming in the legend doesn't really make any sense. Also, the TWW legend says nothing about Sages, but Ganon taking over, and Link coming out of nowhere, and winning.
I'm not saying LttP can't be after OOT, but it can't be its backstory.

DW

This belongs in Timelines really.
­

Bboy94

I don't see how your first point contradicts it. And "other evidence" you are completely paraphrasing. Do a little reading between the lines and use exact quotes when trying this. Because I could do the same thing you do and easily contradict you.

Penguin dude 2

Contadict me then! :) I accept the challenge. Show me how it's possible, even if the seal transcended to the kid timeline! Anyway, I have to do this from memory.

Bboy94

Ok, you could twist it so that the Twilight Realm into being the same as the Dark World.

Mysterious F.

It's been stated they're two seperate things.

Miyamoto has stated OOT was before LTTP, in fact, he put LTTP at the end of his timelnie in 1998.

Well, I suggest you ask Evilslayer for more details, because all of LTTP was mixed around from the Japanese version. Ask him, and you'll know the truth.

Bboy94

I know they are seperate things, I was just doing the same thing he was. And Japanese doesn't mean canon you know.

Mysterious F.

Actually, it is. The Japanese was the original plot made by the game designers, while the American version hcnaged it like 4KIDS changes any anime it gets. The Japanese is the original, even the name Link to the Past is a change.

Penguin dude 2

#8
Theres notable evidence to say the Dark World isn't the Twilight Realm.
1 The interlopers tried to take over the Sacred Realm, and the goddesses banished them to the Twilight Realm.
2Why would they seal them in the place they wanted to go?
3 The Dark World is Ganons versiom of Hyrule. The Twilight Realm is the Twilight Realm.
It's said in the game that the Twilight Realm became known as the Twilight Realm, probably because no one had ever heard of it, and it was perpetual twilight.

DW

Wait, you are calling the sacred realm and the twilight realm the same things there. That's a no-no.
­

Bboy94

 ??? Read the post, people, I don't think it is.
QuoteI know they are seperate things, I was just doing the same thing he was.

Penguin dude 2

Read the edit! I did make it sound like I said they were the same by accident.

Bboy94

I suggest you read the Book of Mudora at TGA, if I remember right, it explains it well.

Mysterious F.

As I said, it's been stated that they are two seperate things by the game producers.

Commodore Axilon

Quote from: The Artist Formerly Known As Whocares on April 14, 2007, 12:18:55 PM
Actually, it is. The Japanese was the original plot made by the game designers, while the American version hcnaged it like 4KIDS changes any anime it gets. The Japanese is the original, even the name Link to the Past is a change.

Except the fact that the English version is also made by Nintendo. So your little analogy there falls flat.